May 5, 2011
Yesterday I was told, if God exists he must have evolved. The “proof” that God must have evolved went something like this:
1) We evolved
2) We are intelligent
3) Therefore intelligence can only form due to evolution
4) If God is intelligent he must have evolved.
(3) doesn’t seem to logically follow. It’s that little word ‘only’ which seems all wrong. Pointing out a specific example doesn’t make a general rule.
I mention this, because although it seems like faulty reasoning to me, after Dawkins it is a popular thing for atheists to repeat. Maybe some of my atheist commenters would like to point out what I’m missing.
The only real response I was given by the guy offering the proof was that I am “too stupid to be an atheist”.